| Rank | Album | Artist | Released | Reviews | Last Review |
| 1 | | Contra | Vampire Weekend | January 12 | 1 listen | 01/15/10 |
| 2 | | Heartland | Owen Pallett | January 12 | 1 listen | 02/06/10 |
| 3 | | Eyelid Movies | Phantogram | February 9 | 1 listen | 06/12/10 |
| 4 | | Two Thousand and Ten Injuries | Love is All | March 30 | 1 listen | 04/09/10 |
| 5 | | Fang Island | Fang Island | February 23 | 1 listen | 06/07/10 |
| 6 | | High Violet | The National | May 11 | 1 listen | 06/06/10 |
| 7 | | Realism | The Magnetic Fields | January 26 | 1 listen | 02/06/10 |
| 8 | | Big Echo | The Morning Benders | March 9 | 1 listen | 06/07/10 |
| 9 | | Travellers in Time and Space | The Apples in Stereo | April 20 | 1 listen | 06/06/10 |
| 10 | | A Coming of Age | Lucky Soul | April 20 | 1 listen | 06/19/10 |
| 11 | | Together | The New Pornographers | May 4 | 1 listen | 06/06/10 |
| 12 | | Pop Cycle | Marching Band | May 18 | 1 listen | 06/19/10 |
| 13 | | Melted | Ty Segall | May 25 | 1 listen | 06/07/10 |
| 14 | | Nothing Hurts | Male Bonding | May 11 | 1 listen | 06/19/10 |
| 15 | | Treats | Sleigh Bells | June 1 | 1 listen | 06/07/10 |
| 16 | | Romance is Boring | Los Campesinos! | January 26 | 1 listen | 02/06/10 |
| 17 | | Topp stemning pĺ lokal bar | Casiokids | May 28 | 1 listen | 04/09/10 |
| 18 | | Astro Coast | Surfer Blood | January 19 | 1 listen | 02/06/10 |
| 19 | | Magic Chairs | Efterklang | February 23 | 1 listen | 04/09/10 |
| 20 | | End Times | eels | January 19 | 1 listen | 02/06/10 |
| 21 | | Teen Dream | Beach House | January 26 | 1 listen | 02/06/10 |
| 22 | | Transference | Spoon | January 19 | 0 listens | |
| 23 | | The Soft Pack | The Soft Pack | February 2 | 0 listens | |
| 24 | | Ugly Side of Love | Malakai | February 2 | 0 listens | |
| 25 | | Measure | Field Music | February 16 | 0 listens | |
| 26 | | Life is Sweet! Nice to Meet You | Lightspeed Champion | February 16 | 0 listens | |
| 27 | | Volume Two | She & Him | March 23 | 0 listens | |
| 28 | | Happy Birthday | Happy Birthday | March 16 | 0 listens | |
| 29 | | The Winter of Mixed Drinks | Frightened Rabbit | March 9 | 0 listens | |
| 30 | | Dirty Shirt Rock 'n' Roll: The First Ten Years | The Jon Spencer Blues Explosion | March 30 | 0 listens | |
| 31 | | I Will Be | Dum Dum Girls | March 3 | 0 listens | |
| 32 | | I Learned the Hard Way | Sharon Jones & The Dap-Kings | April 6 | 0 listens | |
| 33 | | Plastic Beach | Gorillaz | March 9 | 0 listens | |
| 34 | | The Desert of Shallow Effects | Miles Kurosky | March 9 | 0 listens | |
| 35 | | If I Had a Hi-Fi | Nada Surf | June 8 | 0 listens | |
| 36 | | Live at Maxwell's 03.27.10 | Love is All | March 27 | 0 listens | |
| 37 | | The Chaos | The Futureheads | June 1 | 0 listens | |
| 38 | | Shame, Shame | Dr. Dog | April 6 | 0 listens | |
| 39 | | The Wild Hunt | The Tallest Man on Earth | April 13 | 0 listens | |
| 40 | | Go | Jónsi | April 6 | 0 listens | |
| 41 | | Heaven in Whenever | The Hold Steady | May 4 | 0 listens | |
| 42 | | Subiza | Delorean | June 8 | 0 listens | |
| 43 | | Forgiveness Rock Record | Broken Social Scene | May 4 | 0 listens | |
| 44 | | What We Lose in the Fire We Gain in the Flood | The Mynabirds | April 27 | 0 listens | |
| 45 | | Rough Frame | Art Museums | February 16 | 0 listens | |
| 46 | | Warm Slime | Thee Oh Sees | May 11 | 0 listens | |
| 47 | | Congratulations | MGMT | April 9 | 0 listens | |
| 48 | | Have One on Me | Joanna Newsom | February 23 | 0 listens | |
| 49 | | Gorilla Manor | Local Natives | February 16 | 0 listens | |
| 50 | | SP20: Casual Nostalgia Fest | Various Artists | April 17 | 0 listens | |
| 51 | | Broken Bells | Broken Bells | March 9 | 0 listens | |
| 52 | | Expo 86 | Wolf Parade | June 29 | 0 listens | |
| 53 | | Something for Everybody | Devo | June 15 | 0 listens | |
| 54 | | The Drums | The Drums | June 8 | 0 listens | |
| 55 | | InnerSpeaker | Tame Impala | May 25 | 0 listens | |
| 56 | | True Love Casts Out All Evil | Roky Erickson & Okkervil River | April 20 | 0 listens | |
| 57 | | Crazy for You | Best Coast | July 27 | 0 listens | |
| 58 | | Mines | Menomena | July 27 | 0 listens | |
| 59 | | King of the Beach | Wavves | August 3 | 0 listens | |
| 60 | | Release Me | The Like | June 15 | 0 listens | |
| 61 | | Star Tiger Star Ariel | The Delays | June 29 | 0 listens | |
| 62 | | Avi Buffalo | Avi Buffalo | April 27 | 0 listens | |
| 63 | | The Monitor | Titus Andronicus | March 9 | 0 listens | |